Mechanics & Industry
Volume 21, Number 6, 2020
|Number of page(s)||7|
|Published online||21 January 2021|
The impact of inlet flash evaporation conditions on erosion damage characteristics of coal gasification black water angle valve and prevention strategies
Hefei University, School of Advanced Manufacturing Engineering, Hefei 230601, PR China
2 Hefei General Machinery Research Institute Co. Ltd., Department of Valve and Oil Equipment, Hefei 230088, PR China
3 Zhejiang Sci-Tech University, Institute of Flow Induced Corrosion, Hangzhou 310018, PR China
* e-mail: firstname.lastname@example.org
Accepted: 22 November 2020
In view of the three-stage flash evaporation system of the coal gasification plant, a combination of theoretical analysis and numerical simulation was used to establish the erosion damage evaluation model in the black water angle valve. The influence of the inlet flash evaporation ratio on the inlet velocity, the outlet flash evaporation ratio and the outlet velocity of the low-pressure black water angle valve are systematically studied, the mechanism of erosion damage to the carbon steel valve body by the solid medium in black water was analyzed according to the micro-cutting theory. The results show that the inlet velocity w 1, the outlet flash evaporation ratio x 2, the outlet velocity w 2 of angle valve have linear correlation with the inlet flash evaporation ratio x 1.The upstream volume erosion ratio of the angle valve at the inlet flash ratio x 1 = 3 wt.% is 114 times as much as that at zero inlet flash ratio. Meanwhile, the downstream volume erosion ratio of the angle valve at x 1 = 3 wt.% is only 2.7 times as much as that at zero inlet flash ratio. The prevention strategies to reduce the erosion damage to black water angle valve are proposed by inhibiting the inlet flash evaporation ratio and reducing the inlet flow rate etc. This study is expected to provide guidance for the erosion resistance design and operation of the black water angle valve.
Key words: Coal gasification / the black water angle valve / inlet flash evaporation / erosion damage analysis / prevention strategies
© X. Yan et al., Hosted by EDP Sciences 2021
This is an Open Access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License (https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0), which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited.
The coal reserves is the most abundant resources among fossil fuels in China, which is much more than oil and natural gas, therefore, now coal chemical industry has entered into the process of large-scale industrialization under the overall layout of China energy strategy. Coal gasification is one of the key technologies of coal deep processing and has a significant influence on efficient and environment friendly use of coal resource. By the reaction between dry coal power or water coal slurry with oxidants, catalysts, etc. in the gasifier at high temperature and pressure, flammable gases such as CO, H2 and CH4 are generated and used in related fields like industrial chemicals, combined electricity generation and metallurgical reducing gas. The black water flash evaporation system of coal gasification process can efficiently handle the wastewater from gasifying wet wash and slag removal system [1,2]. Black water flash evaporation system often use black water angle valve to control the liquid level in flash tank; while flash evaporation system is constantly exposed in circumstance with high temperature, high pressure and high particle concentration [3,4]. Gas-liquid-solid multiphase flow during the flash evaporation process will cause not only seriously erosion to the inner components and rear pipe of the black water angel valve, but also noise and intense vibration [5–8], which strongly shorten the lifetime of the black water angel valve. With the consideration of listed problems, research works have been carried out by lot of scholars, representatives are: Yan Zhen et al.  simulated the inner flow field characteristic of the valve with k-ε standard turbulence model, and provided an improved structure solution based on the factor of the flash evaporation inside valve; since black water angel valve is similar to 90° pipe, and the velocity of inlet flow has a great impact on the pipe erosion, Peng and Cao  gained a sequence of factors(pipe diameter, inlet velocity, curvature radius, particle mass flow rate, particle diameter, average curvature radius/pipe diameter and bend direction etc.) that influence the erosion by numerical simulation methods, and also established the correlation between the Stoke number and the maximum erosion area with three collision mechanisms which explains how the Stoke number influence erosion area; Mansouri et al.  used an Eulerian–Lagrangian approach to perform the numerical erosion modeling of a 90° sharp bend in water–sand slurry flow. Standard wall-function and low-Re number approach were employed for resolving the near wall region, and the results showed that with low-Re number model, the accuracy of theerosion prediction resulting from small particle will be significantly improved; Guo-Fu et al.  did experimental research on the erosion appearance of austenitic stainless steel A182F347 under the SiO2 and Al2O3 combined abrasive particle condition, hence the erosion mechanism of austenitic stainless steel A182 F347 under the liquid-solid two-phase flow system was revealed; Parsi et al.  pointed the fact that in H-H elbow, maximum erosion occurred at the top of the elbow's outer wall and highly related to parameters such as phase distributions, particle concentration and particle velocity under multiphase flow conditions.
In summation, this article starts with the erosion damage of low pressure black water angel valve that caused by three stage flash evaporation coal gasification system; by using a combination of theoretical analysis and numerical simulation, the effect of inlet flash evaporation conditions on erosion damage characteristics was studied, and with consideration of low pressure black water angle valve process connection method, the result shows the erosion damage mechanism of valve body. Furthermore, prevention strategy on the erosion damage of a black water angle valve is presented and numerical supports and guidance for the erosion resistance design and operation of the black water angle valveare provided.
The black water 3-stage flash evaporation system of a dry pulverized coal gasifier (quench process) with a daily processing capacity of 2200 tons of coal is shown in Figure 1. Black water from gasification quench chamber, scrubber and separator flows into mid-pressure flash tank through mid-pressure black water angle valve LV-0101A. Low-pressure black angle valve LV-0301A and vacuum black angle valve LV-0401A are installed between mid-pressure flash tank, low-pressure flash tank and vacuum flash tank respectively to control the pressure gap and liquid level between different tanks. Meanwhile, the acid gas from flash evaporation will be split out. Then, concentrated black water flows through slag bath to separate fine slag, and reclaimed gray water will ensure an environmental friendly emission of the system.
The system of black water 3-stage flash evaporation.
Low pressure black water valve LV-0301A is a single-seat angel valve with the side entry and bottom exit of 10″-Class 150 (Inlet d 1 = 254 mm, Outlet d 2 = 254 mm). The valve body is made of carbon steel, and seat and spool are made of tungsten carbide. As shown in Figure 1, black water remains saturated at the bottom of mid-pressure flash tank, before entering the low-pressure black water angle valve, the pressure drop from connecting pipe may cause a partial flash evaporation, and accompanied with gas-liquid-solid multiphase flow. Table 1 shows the operation condition of a low-pressure black water angle valve LV-0301A, the inlet flash evaporation ration x 1 ≤ 3wt.%, solid content equals to 3wt.%, particle size <200 μm. As assumption, the medium of the black water angle valve LV-0301A is considered as saturated water.
The condition of black water angle valve LV-0301A.
Firstly, with computational fluid dynamics approach, a numerical simulation analysis of the gas-liquid two-phase flow inside the LV-0301A low-pressure black water angle valve is performed. According to the working conditions of the low-pressure black water angle valve, the average motion of the fluid is described by Reynolds averaged N-S equations (RANS), turbulence is described by the RNG k-ε model, and the phase change process between the liquid and gas phases is described by the evaporative condensation model. Where the transport equation for turbulent kinetic energy k and dissipation rate ε is:(1) (2) With: , η = Sk/ϵ, and σk, σε are the turbulent Prandtl number of the turbulent kinetic energy and its dissipation rate, respectively; C 1 ε, C 2 , σk, σε take values of 1.44, 1.9, 1.0, 1.2, respectively.
When the temperature changes, evaporation or condensation occurs in the gas and liquid phases, which leads to a mass transfer. The gas-liquid mass transfer process could be written as:(3) (4) (5)where αν and αι are gas- and liquid-phase fractions, respectively; ρν and ρι are gas- and liquid-phase densities, respectively; νν is gas-phase velocity, ml→ν and mν→l are masses that transformed by evaporation and condensation, respectively; T and Tsat are local temperature and vapor pressure corresponding temperatures, respectively. The Coeff factor represents the reciprocal of relaxation time, which is:(6)where, d is the vacuolar diameter, β is a regulating factor which indicates the part of the vapor molecule that been absorbed when entering the liquid surface, M is the mass of the gas phase, R is the universal gas constant, and L is the latent heat of vaporization.
The flow field gas phase fractions of a black water angle valve including a buffer tank is simulated, and the relevant parameters are as follows, x 1 = 0, P 1 = 6.5 bar, Δp = 3.5 bar, W = 135636 kg/h, and 40% opening, as shown in Figure 2.
Figure 2 shows a large amount of gas flash evaporate into venturi tube and buffer tanks downstream the valve. The cross-sections between the spool outlet and the valve outlet are divided into three, which are 1–1, 2–2 and 3–3 to show the changes of their flash evaporation rates. 1–1 is located at the spool outlet, where only the local gas phase is present in the flow field, and the maximum gas phase fraction is only 20%, with an overall flash evaporation ratio of 0.3 wt.%. The 2–2 is located upstream of the valve outlet, where the phase fraction increases and its maximum value shows around the tube, which can reach up to 70%, but the overall flash evaporation ratio is only 1.2 wt.%. The 3–3 cross section is located at the valve outlet with a maximum phase fraction of 90%, the overall flash evaporation ratio is increased to 5 wt.%.
The distribution of gas phase fraction in the internal flow field of black water angle valve.
The distribution of fluid velocity and motion pattern in black water angle valve is shown in Figure 3:
Figure 3 shows the distribution of fluid velocity in black water angel valve. As can be seen in the figure, high velocity area distributes from downstream of the spool outlet to the valve outlet section, with a low level of acceleration and an average speed of about 25 m/s. Flow rates are relatively low upstream of the valve and downstream of the valve outlet in the venturi pipe and buffer tank with intense evaporation. It can be concluded that high risk area of erosion is located from the spool to valve outlet section, where the calculation of the fluid velocity is particularly important. As can be seen from the local flow diagram as well as the flow diagram of the 1–1 cross section, there are apparently some unstable vortices near the downstream of the spool that can cause vibration and noise in the valve. Comparing with the gas phase fraction plotted in Figure 2, one can see the locations with higher gas phase fraction overlapped the center of the vortex, that is, the local flash evaporation ratio increased due to the pressure reduction caused by the vortex, which is a high risk area for erosion failure.
The distribution of fluid velocity and motion pattern in black water angle valve.
To verify the accuracy of the predicted results, a low-pressure black water angle valve was dissected after validated six months commissioning under typical operating conditions. As shown in Figure 4, the upstream body of the black water angle valve cavity is severely eroded, and the wall thickness is significantly thinner and even perforated.
Comparing Figures 2–4, it can be seen that the angle valve upstream body erosion failure area found by strip inspection is located in the narrow channel of the outlet throat of the spool, which corresponds to the area near cross-section 1–1 in Figures 2 and 3. Due to inlet flash evaporation and straight pipe throttling, the internal fluid velocity abruptly changed from nearly 9 m/s (x 1 = 3 wt.%) of inlet flow velocity to nearly 38 m/s of outlet flow velocity. The higher flow velocity and local vortex caused by flash evaporation are two of the main factors that cause the upstream body damage of the black water angle valve. The results of strip inspection remains consistent with numerical predictions.
The erosion damage morphology of upstream body of black water angle valve LV-0301A.
The above CFD-based numerical analysis described gives a good indication of the flow and flash characteristics in the black water angle valve, but the numerical calculations requires relatively longer time. For improving the efficiency of numerical calculation, the development of a more concise mathematical model to characterize the average flow velocity in the valve is critical for valve erosion failure analysis and erosion resistance optimization design and implementation. To facilitate the analysis, the gas-liquid two-phase flow is considered as a mixed single-phase medium, and the inlet medium mixed density ρm 1 of the angle valve is calculated by equation (7), while the velocity w 1 of the inlet gas-liquid mixed medium of the angle valve is calculated by equation (8).(7) (8)
With inlet liquid specific enthalpy ; inlet steam specific enthalpy ; outlet liquid specific enthalpy and outlet steam specific enthalpy .
The mixing density ρm 2 of the outlet medium of the angle valve is calculated according to equation (11), and the velocity of the outlet gas-liquid mixing medium of the angle valve is calculated according to equation (12).(11) (12)
Considering different inlet flash ratios x 1, the data in Table 1 are substituted by equations (7)–(12) separately, to obtain different inlet velocity w 1 and outlet velocity w 2 for the evaluation of the black water angle valve.
In order to analyze and evaluate the erosion caused by rigid particles in carbon steel valve body, the following equation for the erosion rate m is concluded as a function of the inlet angle α [14,15]:(13)
where c is the particle fraction, M is the mass of the particle, vs is the particle velocity and p is the elastic flow pressure between the particle and the target. When only considering the change of particle velocity, equation (13) shows that the volumetric erosion rate m of the carbon steel valve body of black water angle valve is positively correlated with the velocity of solid particles vs powered by n, and n = 2.2 is picked for further calculation.
The inlet flash ratio x 1 has an effect on w 1 , x 2 , w 2; for a common working condition in Table 1, when different x 1 substitute into equations (7)–(12), the relationship between outlet flash ratio x 2 and the inlet flash ratio x 1, the inlet velocity w 1 (outlet velocity w 2) and the inlet flash ratio x 1 can be obtained respectively, as shown in Figures 5 and 6.
As shown in Figure 5, when the inlet flash ratio x 1 is 0%, the corresponding outlet flash ratio x 2 is 4.83 wt.%; when x 1 > 0, the outlet flash ratio x 2 follows the equation: x 2 ≈ x 1 + 4.83%. As shown in Figure 6, when the inlet flash ratio of medium increases by every Δx 1 = 0.5%, the inlet and outlet velocity w 1, w 2 will be increased by 1.24, 2.20 m/s respectively.
For further discussion and analyzing the connection between the inlet flash ratio x 1 and the inlet and outlet velocity of the black water angle valve, the relationship between the inlet flash ratio and the relative increment of the inlet and outlet velocity is graphed, as shown in Figure 7. Observing Figures 6 and 7, we can see that when x 1 = 0.125 wt.%, the inlet and outlet flow rates w 1 and w 2 of the angle valve are 1.30 and 23.39 m/s respectively, and their relative increments are 32.65% and 2.36% respectively. As x 1 continues to increase, the inlet and outlet flow rates increase linearly, but the relative increase in flow rate gradually slows.
According to the rigid particles erosion rate of the carbon steel valve body expressed in equation (13), comparing the upstream and downstream volume erosion damage ratios at x 1 = 0 and x 1 > 0, the correspondence effect of inlet flash ratio on upstream and downstream relative volume erosion damage ratio is obtained, as shown in Figure 8.
In Figure 8, the upstream relative volume erosion damage ratio of the angle valve at x 1 = 3 wt.% is 114 times as much as that at x 1 = 0. Obviously, the high-speed flash flow which formed by the flash evaporation of the liquid phase on upstream of the valve causes a significant damage to the upstream valve, especially in the vortex area near the throat of the valve body. While the downstream relative volume erosion damage ratio of the angle valve at x 1 = 3 wt.% is only 2.7 times as much as that at x 1 = 0, it can be expected that the increase of inlet flash ratio has a relative small effect on the erosion damage to the downstream valve.
The effect of inlet flash ratio x 1 on outlet flash ratio x 2.
The effect of inlet flash ratio on velocity.
The effect of inlet flash ratio on relative increment.
The effect of inlet flash ratio on upstream and downstream relative volume erosion damage ratio.
According to the working conditions listed in Table 1, the gas phase fraction at the inlet of the black water angle valve is an important factor in the destruction of the valve body upstream of the angle valve. First, the inlet flash ratio should be inhibited as small as possible; at the same time, prevention strategies such as increasing the inlet diameter or enlarging the middle cavity of the valve body to reduce inlet impact velocity, hardening the upstream of the angle valve to resist the impact abrasion, and distributing the flow guide device to disperse the impact of the inlet fluid are also adopted. As the black water of the three-stage flash evaporation system is recycled, lack of the freshwater replenishment may cause the corrosive water leading to an erosion and corrosion coupling damage. Thus, it is suggested to replace the carbon steel valve body with stainless steel to improve the corrosion resistance of the low-pressure black water angle valve.
For the internal flow characteristics of the three-stage flash evaporation system of coal gasification, CFD numerical simulations were used to obtain the distribution of gas phase fractions and flow velocities inside the black water angle valve under typical working conditions, and the numerical predictions confirm that the upstream area near the valve trim is a high-risk area for erosion, and the dissection results remain consistent with the predicted results.
A characterization model of the erosion was developed, and the effect of the inlet flash ratio on the outlet flash ratio and the inlet/outlet velocity of black water angle valve was obtained. The outlet flash ratio, inlet and outlet velocity increase linearly with the increase of inlet flash ratio. When the inlet flash rate is 0.125 wt.%, the inlet flow rate and outlet flow rate are 1.3 and 23.39 m/s respectively, and their relative changes amount to 32.65% and 2.36% respectively. As the inlet flash ratio increases, velocity increases linearly, but the relative increment of velocity slows down;
The upstream volume erosion ratio of the angle valve at x 1 = 3 wt.% is 114 times as much as that at x 1 = 0. Meanwhile, the downstream volume erosion ratio of the angle valve at x 1 = 3 wt.% is only 2.7 times as much as that at x 1 = 0, so the damage on upstream valve body caused by increasement of inlet flash ratio is more severe than the damage on downstream valve body.
Inhibiting the inlet flash ratio as small as possible, increasing the valve inlet diameter, appropriately expanding the valve body cavity, hardening treatment of upstream angle valve, using deflector to disperse inlet fluid erosion, using stainless steel valve body and other strategies would reduce or avoid erosion damage to the upstream body of black water angle valve.
Fund Projects: National Key R & D Program Project (2018YFB2004002); Anhui Provincial Key Research and Development Program Project (1804a09020004); Anhui Provincial Universities Natural Science Research Key Project (KJ2018A0551).
- Z. Yu, Y. Chen, D. Feng et al., Process development, simulation, and industrial implementation of a new coal-gasification wastewater treatment installation for phenol and ammonia removal, Industrial & Engineering Chemistry Research 49, 2874–2881 (2010) [Google Scholar]
- X. An-Dong, D. Zheng-Hua, L. Xin-Yu et al., Process optimization of gasification black water treatment system, Chemical Engineering 45, 19–24 (2017) [Google Scholar]
- O. Guo-Fu, Y. Yu-Wei, J. Hao-Zhe et al., Numerical simulation and optimization on coal liquefaction decompression charge-in valve, Journal of China Coal Society 40, 2961–2966 (2015) [Google Scholar]
- G.F. Ou, P.W. Ouyang, Z.J. Zheng et al., Investigation on failure process and structural improvement of a high-pressure coal water slurry valve, Engineering Failure Analysis 96, 1–17 (2019) [Google Scholar]
- J.R. Keiser, O.C. Dias, J.R. Mayotte, Analysis of pipe failure at the Great Plains Coal Gasification Plant, Materials Characterization 33, 147–153 (1994) [Google Scholar]
- G. Ou, K. Bie, Z. Zheng et al., Numerical simulation on the erosion wear of a multiphase flow pipeline, The International Journal of Advanced Manufacturing Technology 96, 1705–1713 (2017) [CrossRef] [Google Scholar]
- W. Wei, C. Feng-Guan, M. You et al., CFD Analysis of the flow channel structure for hydraulic decoking three—way valve, Fluid Machinery 40, 25–28 (2012) [Google Scholar]
- W. Wei, Y. Shan-Wen, C. Feng-Guan et al., Effect of trim modification of hydraulic decoking three-way valve on the pump-outlet pressure, Fluid Machinery 41, 48–53 (2013) [Google Scholar]
- Y. Zhen, W. Huan, L. Feng et al., Numerical simulation of flashing and structural improvements on black water regulating valve, Chemical Engineering & Machinery 41, 642–646 (2014) [Google Scholar]
- W. Peng, X. Cao, Numerical simulation of solid particle erosion in pipe bends for liquid–solid flow, Powder Technology 294, 266–279 (2016) [Google Scholar]
- A. Mansouri, H. Arabnejad, S. Karimi et al., Improved CFD modeling and validation of erosion damage due to fine sand particles, Wear 338–339, 339–350 (2015) [Google Scholar]
- O. Guo-Fu, L. Xu, J. Hao-Zhe et al., Erosion resistance of A182F347 stainless steel in liquid-solid two phase flow system, Journal of China Coal Society 41, 2883–2888 (2016) [Google Scholar]
- M. Parsi, M. Kara, M. Agrawal et al., CFD simulation of sand particle erosion under multiphase flow conditions, Wear 376–377, 1176–1184 (2016) [Google Scholar]
- I. Finnie, G.R. Stevick, J.R. Ridgely, The influence of impingement angle on the erosion of ductile metals by angular abrasive particles, Wear 152, 91–98 (1992) [Google Scholar]
- I. Finnie, D.H. Mcfadden, On the velocity dependence of the erosion of ductile metals by solid particles at low angles of incidence, Wear 48, 181–190 (1978) [Google Scholar]
Cite this article as: X. Yan, W. Wei, M. You, L. Fan-Ding, J. Hao-Zhe, The impact of inlet flash evaporation conditions on erosion damage characteristics of coal gasification black water angle valve and prevention strategies, Mechanics & Industry 21, 626 (2020)
The distribution of gas phase fraction in the internal flow field of black water angle valve.
|In the text|
The erosion damage morphology of upstream body of black water angle valve LV-0301A.
|In the text|
Current usage metrics show cumulative count of Article Views (full-text article views including HTML views, PDF and ePub downloads, according to the available data) and Abstracts Views on Vision4Press platform.
Data correspond to usage on the plateform after 2015. The current usage metrics is available 48-96 hours after online publication and is updated daily on week days.
Initial download of the metrics may take a while.